PDA

View Full Version : Outside opinions/input desperately wanted.



Peter McCoy
May 5th, 2011, 06:05:12 PM
I'm in an awkward situation right now. This is a long post so I sincerely thank anybody who sticks it out to offer some help/criticism since I'm really mindfucked right now.

Basically, a friend of the family asked my dad if me and my fiance wouldn't mind if his little girl could be a bridesmaid at our wedding. When my dad told me, I said sure thing, though I did find it completely out of the blue considering the first and only time I'd met the kid was less than a fortnight ago at our engagement party. So my fiance is at ours the next evening and my mum asked me had I aske dher. I'd forgotten, so asked there and then. She said yes (feeling a bit on the spot and under pressure in fornt of my mum and dad), commenting that she'd like to meet her properly and get to know her a bit better.

Two days later, my fiance tells me that she doesn't feel comfortable having a kid she does not know in the slightest being one of her bridesmaids. This is also in repsonse to her remembering that she'd said no to her auntie's grandchildren being bridesmaids for exactly the same reasons - she's never met them even once, and how bad it would look if she were to have a strange kid be a bridesmaid.

This point of view, I completely understand. But from my perspective, I didn't think it a big deal to have an extra bridesmaid. The only thing was it was the daughter of a very close family friend who does favours for which I am very grateful. I've known him for years so I'm sure people can understand that I'd want to do him a favour such as this in return. But that doesn't change the fact that honouring said request would mean having a kid we hardly know as a bridesmaid at the biggest day of our lives.

After talking it over tonight, I've supported my fiance's position, and called our friend to tell him that, regrettably, we can't have the kid as a bridesmaid for said reason. He was perfectly understanding, there was no malice involved, we had our usual banter and joking before the end of the conversation. All seeme dhunky dory.

I get home tonight and my mum is absolutely seething. I don't know if she's spoken to our friend or if this is just a delayed rant form when I told her the night before about not having the kid as a bridesmaid. He opinion is this: the friend of the family in question has done a lot for us, favours etc such as helping decorate, giving lifts to the airport in the past, fixing PC's etc. The other side to my mothers coin is the wedding itself - namely that I'm not having any say in what gets done regarding the wedding and that my fiance is in total control.

Now in all honesty, fuck all's been set in stone for now. I couldn't give a shit about the designs or colours of the dresses, nor the suits as long as me and the rest of the guys (dad, Droo etc) don't look like a gang of gobshites in monkey suits. If it's something I have an opinion about, such as table dressings, decor, banner,s balloons, flowers, the cake, venue, food etc, I'll be dictating 50% of it. From my perspectivre, the bridesmaids are the brides domain. My only sibling, my sister, is to be one, which I'm thrilled with. At first her reaction to the possibility of being asked was 'Do I have to?' which suggested to me that she wasn't too keen. I'm not one to force anything on anyone so my responce was 'I'd like you to be, but you don't have to if you don't want to, it's really up to you and I won't think any less of you if you say no' - or words to that effect, it was some time ago now.

Another thing my mum decides to share with me all of a sudden - apparently my side of the family were outcasts at the engagement party, who ended up getting shafted with the fewest, worst tables left in the gaff. For starters, my side of the family arrived pretty much entirely AFTER my fiance's did, so the laws of natural selection were in full effect there. And as for being outcasts - I'm lucky if I spoke three words with any of my fiance's relatives all night - I was hovering from my mum and dads table, to my own friends, to my auntie and uncle's table, back to the folks etc. On reflection I felt kinda bad I'd not really sat with my future mother and father in law et al all night. But no, appraently I'm a twat to my own.

So back to tonight, the explanation as to why my fiance had said no to my friends daughter being a bridesmaid fell on deaf ears, along with the fact that my dad (who was and currently is in bed by the time I got home as he usually is) is fuming just as much as my mum is. My mum has suggested its better if my fiance doesn't come down tomorrow night like she usually does every friday night - the same night my dads friend usually visits every week where we all usually get on like a house on fire every week, because she doesn't want there to be an awkward atmosphere.

Now unless my friend was not bieng genuine on the phone earlier when I spoke about his daughter, which I highly doubt because I've never known their to be a deceitful bone in his body, the only awkwardness to be had will be on my parents behalf towards my fiance's decision.

Now there's been issues in the past with my parents, for want of a better expression, despising my fiance for reason I've never grasped. And there were some pretty hurtful things said about my fiance, which I'm certain my mum would never admit and has probably convinced herself she never said. But after her not being welcome in our house for over a year, some forgotten time ago (14 months or so) I decided enough is enough, we'd be getting married some day so the childishness had to stop, 'she'll eventually be my wife so deal with it' sorta thing and I invited her that very night for dinner. Things had been brilliant since then - until this display when I got home just under two hours ago.

Am I delusional? Should I demand to have a say in who my fiance's bridesmaids are? I'm under the impression it's perfectly normal for the bride to have the final say over her bridesmaids, same way I have the final say over the best man and what the guys wear and who I want to have matching suits etc. Putting myself in my fiance's shoes, I totally agree with her - I wouldn't want to be expected to have a non-family members kid I've never met be involved in a personal, intimate part of a huge event such as a wedding, no matter how close or helpful said friend is.

If she didn't give a shit, then I wouldn't give a shit as well and the kid can be two bridesmaids. But it matters to my fiance so it matters to me? I suppose you could say that our wedding day is the one day in our lives we're allowed to be as selfish as we damned well please. Would you agree? Is she being a bitch? Please help make some sense of all this, it's so frustrating. Seriously, the friggin' things going through my mind right now about tomorrow night, and the immediate future in general! (should I move out since they're so awkward and unwelcoming etc etc etc)

Oh, I told my mum my fiance would be coming round tomorrow as normal. As far as I'm concerned, whatever happens - happens, and I'll be standing by my fiance all the way - if my dad has anything to say about that then he can say it to the mirror image of himself since that's exactly the way he is with anything concerning my mum.

Thanks for reading this guys. If anything's kerfuffled or reads like nonesense, just ask - I typed pretty quickly and frustratedly as I'm sure you can imagine.

Park Kraken
May 5th, 2011, 06:12:51 PM
Well, first of all sorry for your troubles, but second of all issues like these are perfectly normal when it comes to weddings. In the last ten years I've been to both of my sister's weddings, plus a few cousins and nieces weddings (with another cousin getting married in June in Houston), and there's been plenty of conflict to go around, so don't feel too bad about having such a situation occur.

My advice would be either try and get to know the kid (maybe you and the Fiancee could babysit the girl for a couple of days?), and then maybe give it a second thought for the benefit of the friends on behalf of all they've done for the family?

Jane
May 5th, 2011, 06:20:23 PM
I have no idea how you guys do weddings in England, but here the bride chooses her bridesmaids. Generally they are family and friends, usually adults. If you want kids in the wedding party they're flower girls or a ring bearer.

I think your mom is being totally unreasonable. Asking to be in someone's wedding party is so bizarre to me - it's just not done. (this is LD btw)

Tear
May 5th, 2011, 06:22:14 PM
I think you and your fiance need to sit down with your parents and talk this through. She needs to be there to speak with your parents about how she feels, face to face. With you there to support her decision while also acting as a mediator on behalf of your parents concerns as well.

Represent both sides, let them both half their say and come to some sort of understanding or compromise.

I recently watched a close friend of mine get married. His parents and sister had several issues with how the wedding went down and put the blame solely on his fiance. He took up his fiances side and now he doesn't speak with his parents.

Obviously, this is an extreme case but I know they were never able to get to the point where they could talk it out in a reasonable matter because things just kept escalating. Small things at first, leading eventually to bigger issues until both parties weren't reconcilable. It was a horrible thing to watch happen.

Good luck buddy. Hope this gets settled for ya.;)

Polly Smithson
May 5th, 2011, 07:06:46 PM
Oh dear, what an awful situation. :(

To me, this is pretty well a non-issue. And judging by the way you`ve expressed your and your fiancee`s mindset, as well as the reaction of your friend, it is, too. Whatever is setting your parents off is their own ballgame.

As has been said, I think there definitely needs to be some kind of dialogue between the four of you, whether it does any good or not. Maybe a little perspective is needed - this isn`t about a bid for prominence between your side or hers, or a show of favouritism, it`s the blending together of two lives and two families and it`s meant to be a joyous occasion? And while you would hope to have them support and embrace that process, it`s certainly up to them to choose to do so.

I have to say it`s really heartwarming to see just how very considerate you are of your fiancee`s feelings and thoughts. It`s very clear that you two are on the same page and no doubt she gets a lot of comfort from the fact that you back her up. Weddings and family are tough lands to navigate sometimes. :(

:hug Here`s hoping it gets better!

Figrin D'an
May 5th, 2011, 07:14:14 PM
I'd echo the sentiment that you and your fiance need to sit down with your parents, privately, and discuss the bridesmaid issue and the larger issue perceived 'control' issue regarding the planning of the wedding. It's going to be painful, but it has to be done.

That said, it's my opinion that you need to back your fiance, particularly since you seem to be in agreement with her on the wedding plans and are comfortable with the relative decision making power between the two of you on various preparations. This is the woman who will be your wife, and the wedding day is about you and her, not anyone else. Your parents, and anyone whom has their ear, need to understand this. They may be upset, and will argue that they should have a say since they are your parents, but you need to stand firm and be clear that it isn't their choice. Your wedding is about you and your fiance celebrating your love for one another, and sharing that statement with your friends and family. That is your gift to them, and I emphasize "gift". You are allowing those people to be witness to that event, by your choice. Without your and your fiance, there is no celebration. Anyone wanting to nitpick and unduly influence needs to keep that fact in mind.

From my cultural perspective (American speaking here), it's completely inappropriate for anyone to ask to be in someone else's wedding. The bride and groom always have control over whom is in their wedding party (bridesmaids, groomsmen, ring bearer, flower girl(s), etc) and how large it will be.


I don't envy you having to deal with this. Planning a wedding can be stressful enough without any added drama.

Atreyu
May 5th, 2011, 07:21:38 PM
Sorry to hear about your situation. :\ I'm single so I can't really offer any advice from personal experience, although what the others have said sounds good (in particular sitting down with everybody and trying to hash it out).

One thing I will note though - you said you had issues 14 months ago, then you decided to get married so you put your foot down and it's been 'brilliant' ever since. I strongly suspect it was never actually brilliant - your family was probably putting up with it all; it's just been this latest incident that has brought old feelings back and why it's now suddenly a problem all over again. Making an issue out of declining your family friend's request regarding his daughter smells like a ruse by your mother to be honest - from what you've described I'd daresay she just has issues with your fiancee (for whatever reason) and she's now using this situation to reignite all the problems she's been sitting on for ages.

Hope you manage to clear some things up regardless. Weddings can be funny things - for a day that is supposed to be so memorable in one's life it often seems to bring so much angst and stress and arguments. My brother got married a couple of years ago - our family plus his fiancee's had always gotten along so well but even so in the planning stages our mother seemed to get a bit snippy about the fiancee and her mother seemed to be deciding everything and she was being pushed aside. I guess everyone just likes leaving their stamp on such days. :x

Morgan Evanar
May 5th, 2011, 07:29:32 PM
It's your wedding and what anyone outside of your fiance wants is secondary.

Atreyu
May 5th, 2011, 07:40:03 PM
Out of curiosity, who's paying for the wedding? (you might have mentioned this already but if so I missed it sorry). Depending on who's footing the bill this can create expectations of control and who has a say in organising the show.

Aurelias Kazaar
May 5th, 2011, 11:11:18 PM
It's your wedding and what anyone outside of your fiance wants is secondary.

What he said. But talking with your parents isn't a bad idea either.

Peter McCoy
May 6th, 2011, 01:55:23 AM
Thanks for the advice so far guys. As mentioned, my fiance will be coming round tonight as she does every friday, so there'll be some sort of talk whether my parents want it or not. And frankly I doubt my mum could keep quiet even if she wanted to.

The issues a while ago were resolved long before our engagement - we only got engaged this February. There literally has not been one single issue. My mum and bride to be have gotten on well together, just the other week my mum gave her an expensive set of designer frames because they were ones bought for my sister but she did not want them. She could have sold them for £150. Same with a coat she bought that wasn't the right size. She still had the receipt and the time to take it back for a refund, but gave it to my fiance instead. Would you really give such things to someone you didn't like? Even my dads gotten on great with her, as they did before the problems. They support opposing football teams and the banter they have is great and fun.

As for paying, myself and she will be paying for the entire thing unless we are offered any help. There's certainly nothing mentioned at the moment about anybody else paying towards it.

As for what some people have mentioned about reconsidering/compromising and perhaps babysitting the girl to get to know her - does that really seem like something you would do? As it is, I don't babysit anybody. I've never been asked to babysit anybody, I never offer to babysit anybody. Does it really seem normal to offer to babysit someone just to get to know them better with the ultimate goal of that kid becoming a bridesmaid. It's like the only reason we'd have bothered to do that was solely to ask her to be a bridesmaid. People may go out of their own way to become a part of such an occasion, but flipping it round and you yourself going out of your way for someone else to be involved is just bizarre, especially if its someone you know absolutely nothing about beyond their name.

The request itself caught me by surprise to be honest. If the shoe were on the other foot I'd be exactly the same. If a friend of her family asked if her son could wear a suit along with my, my dad, the best man and my three very close friends, I'd be like "Why would they even ask that? Why would they even expect that to be okay? I don't know the kid, the kid surely will be uncomfortable about it wouldn't they? Standing with people he doesn't know." And looking back in years to come, in photographs I'd be "Who the hell is that kid?"

I just find it a very strange thing to ask someone. Fair enough if she'd been round to ours a few times with her dad and I'd gotten to know her and we got on well. But to just initiate such a dialogue/relationship for the purpose of the whole bridesmaid thing, it's just odd and doesn't sit well with me.

Jane
May 6th, 2011, 02:05:57 AM
Dont do the babysitting thing, Kraken's advice was bad. ;) Don't feel weird that you find it bizarre someone would ask for their kid you don't know to be in the wedding - it is freaking bizarre.

I hope everything goes well tonight for you and you fiancée :)

Yog
May 6th, 2011, 05:51:12 AM
It's your wedding and what anyone outside of your fiance wants is secondary.

This.

Your mom is being totally unreasonable. You're a grown up man. You're the one paying the wedding. It is your life and your choice. The party / ceremony is your gift to them. Before making drama about such a minor issue, she should remind herself you did not ran off to Vegas and having Elvis marry you with a transvestite, which would have been totally within your right.. :)

Razielle Alastor
May 6th, 2011, 10:28:07 AM
Just a late coming echo here, but I am siding with the 'back your fiance' crowd. For all reasons previously stated, and also for the fact that despite whatever favors this friend of the family has done over the years, that's him - not his daughter. If he wanted permission to give you guys a toast at the reception as an uncle sort or even, read an epic poem at the ceremony, whatever! That would reciprocate the nod to the favors, but it is totally unreasonable of him to expect you to include a girl you just met into one of the most special events of your life. That should be shared only with those people close to both of you that you chose and you should not be made to feel badly about it!

^_^; and now I'm ranting..

Pierce Tondry
May 6th, 2011, 12:02:05 PM
Since I'm older today, I'll dispense some wisdom that comes with my age.

Mate, if all goes well you're going to have one fucking wedding in your lifetime. Make it a day YOU are happy with. Not one someone else is happy with.

Dasquian Belargic
May 7th, 2011, 04:58:19 AM
In my liimted experience I don't think I can add anything that hasn't been said already, but just wanted to wish you and your lady the best luck in sorting this out Peter.

Tom Harriman
May 7th, 2011, 03:05:31 PM
Hey Peter - bit late showing up with advice; I hope things went ok with your lady and your parents last night!

I've been on your fiancée's side of the equation before. I'm not sure I can offer you any "advice"; but I think it's worth bearing in mind that as far as your parents are concerned, you are always going to be their baby. Though misguided, it seems to me like they're trying to look out for you, making sure that you're an equal partner in the wedding plans, that you aren't getting walked all over, etc. They are of course being completely unreasonable, and I hope you told them as much last night: but when it comes to worrying about their kids, parents can get a little crazy.

Basically... I hope your fiancée isn't taking it personally, because I'm sure it isn't. They've just picked a really piss-poor issue to try and stick up for you on.

skinnerr
Oct 5th, 2011, 03:48:51 AM
Unfortunately such troubles are quite normal when it comes to wedding. Fact is: You can't be everybody's darling. My brother married a few years ago and they had an argument about which London florist (http://www.serenataflowers.com/sendflowers/London.htm) would be the best for their wedding. Everyone had his own opinion on that and it was very hard to compound. Nevertheless I hope your wedding was wonderful and everything worked out for you.

Sanis Prent
Oct 5th, 2011, 07:44:39 AM
The only constant here is that stupid shit will be argued over in planning a wedding. This Always Happens

Peter McCoy
Oct 6th, 2011, 02:28:44 PM
Thread necromancy or what!?

Things seem to be okay for now. We've set a date - 18th August next year. That is of course assuming I do get another job by the time this place closes in April.

Atreyu
Oct 7th, 2011, 06:58:24 AM
Thread necromancy or what!?
Yeah, it seemed a bit bizarre to suddenly have this thread pop up with more advice 5 months after you asked for it. o_O

Regardless, it's good to hear that things seemed to have sorted themselves out. :)

Peter McCoy
Oct 7th, 2011, 10:58:09 AM
We've set a date - 18th August next year.

Droo has me doubting myself now. He says I told him the 11th of August. This means I now have to ask the missus which date it is, at which point she'll probably shout at me because I've forgotten. LOL! :)

Morgan Evanar
Oct 7th, 2011, 12:27:32 PM
Google calendar.

Droo
Oct 7th, 2011, 01:01:27 PM
You said August 11th. :colbert

Crusader
Oct 7th, 2011, 01:35:01 PM
We've set a date - 18th August next year.

Droo has me doubting myself now. He says I told him the 11th of August. This means I now have to ask the missus which date it is, at which point she'll probably shout at me because I've forgotten. LOL! :)

If things go wrong, you can always get additional council here even 3 months after you have sorted things out.