Rate the Avatar/Signature Above You

[Dasquian Belargic]

Simple game. Tell us what you think of the avatar and signature of the person above you - score it out of 10 perhaps (10 being awesome, 1 being awful)! Alas, there is no one above me to rate. Person who posts beneath me... do not be too harsh on this poor Rebel

[Lilaena De'Ville]

I give you an 8. But your sigs are random and vastly different and I can only rate the one I see at the moment. ;)

edit: its the D&G white background plain one.

[Dasquian Belargic]

Alright, if the sigs are random, specify which one is showing up :mneh

I see your 'Bloodstained Life' sig right now - I like that you have a theme which runs through this set, to match the avatar, so I'll give it an 8 :D

[Ecks]

only an eight! :shakefist

;)

[Travis North]

I give 8 for Ecks since the character looks badass but the text in the bottom left confuses me.

[Salem Ave]

Avatar - he looks so smiley and happy. Not what I expect from a man of his position :mneh

Still, I think 7 overall. You should get a Steve Bacic sig to match the avatar ;)

[Darven]

Avatar and sig nicely match. The sig I think is really well done, but it's not as sinister as I would imagine the character (in either mode) to be. Callidus' half looks too cheerful, IMO.

Anyway, overall I rate it 8 points.

(I've got two sigs on rotation, so might need to add which one you're seeing)

[Miranda Tarkin]

Darven and some troopers in the back

10. I love it, the borders too

[Captain Monmoo]

a ten very pretty!

[Ilias Nytrau]

5. Much too simple.

[Tristan Heller]

Bonus points recieved for having a matching avatar and signature, and the comedy value of Ilias picking his nose. ;) I do find the lext a little difficult to read at times, but I think that's more to do with my eyes being screwy than anything else.

An 8 1/2 overall, I think. :)

[Captain Monmoo]

10 again i like it very much, capt sheppard is awesome!!!

what do you mean, too simple? Its a minimalist sig.

[Zero]

There's nothing wrong with simple, though if you want to spruce it up, you can check out the fonts thread (http://sw-fans.net/forum/showthread.php?t=16388) over in the Starving Artists' Apartment. Sometimes new fonts can give you inspiration. :)

[Loklorien s'Ilancy]

I really like how the red in the sig brings out the red in the avatar. Has a very comic book feeling to it, which lends well to the setting he's in. Overall I give it an 8 :)

[Jesimae Lawson]

I have always loved your sigs and I do love this one, looks simple but probably was hard to make lol. Or not! Haha! My only beef, I thought it was a tad too dark, but still a great one! I'll say...9 :)

Whoever rates my sig...keep in mind this was my first attempt lol!

[Feral]

For a first attempt, it's a very good one. Then again, I'm not exactly an art critic either. An A for effort at least, so a 10.

[Flux]

No sig, but that's good art. I rate it 9.

[Miranda Tarkin]

I don't know how to make sigs/avatars. I rely on the kindness of others like, Morgan, LD, Dasq, and sil :glomp So if you rate, you are rating on their awesomeness!

Sig and Avatar are funny because they show two exceedingly different sides of the character. 8 overall

[Freight Train]

So...do we rate you again? :huh Anyway, further up is your Sin City black/white/red sig. Looks good, but I'm not really feeling the writing on the face. 7.

[Dragon]

I might have gone with a font that has more of a sense of movement to it, but this is a good, clean concept and a nice tagline. :) I can appreciate how painstaking it can be to mask out a character for a transparent sig. It looks great against black.

As for the avatar, I love the expression. It's dead on for Freight Train.

Sig: 7/10
Av: 9/10

[Stern]

The Comic Book boxes and fonts has always been cool to me. It definitely underscores the idea of the X-Men universe. The signature doesn't really match the avatar though so it brings it down a ste. Either one on their own would probably rate a 9, but together it's at least a 7.

[Vega Van-Derveld]

8 for the avatar. It looks quite iconic.

[Nya Halcyon]

No sig for Vega?

Okay, I'll rate the avatar then:
On its own it's quite simple. But with the CT above it, and the location underneath, it makes a really fitting statement. So 9/10.

(And I've also got two sigs on rotation, so state which, ven if there's not much difference)

[Milivikal k'Vik]

8/10. Excellent, consistent design, but not enough variety in the images between the two signatures.

[Darven]

Ahh don't I know it... unfortunately I don't have more then two images of her available since it's customised artwork and the artist hasn't had the time to do more.... hopefully that'll change soon...

Looking at the Mili sig above now: The one in brown/red/white, where there's a pic of her with ruby red lips and a wide black choke collar around her neck....

Nice design and layout, but the name disappears a bit against the background. Also - is that the same actress?!!? she doesn't look the same with that lipstick on.
I give it 9/10.

[Yog]

One of the better Boba Fett avatars I seen. 9/10

Now rate me! :)

[Dasquian Belargic]

Classic slogan in the avatar, 9 :D

[Thall]

Aargh - Dasq has posted twice and was already rated the fist time. I'll just rate the avatar. :)

Simple, no extra effects or style added. Probably a little bit bland, but if you like Legolas it won't matter. I give it a 7.

::waits to see how people will rate his ye olde olde HTML sig::

[Doktor Klaus Heidegger]

Hard to really see the image on your avatar, so a 3. The signature is also kind of basic. But the old school look of the picture is kind of cool. So 5

[Anna Fernandez]

7 for the use of Doogie!!! no sig :(

[Shadow Storm]

EDIT: Right, too big byte-wise.

So anyways, on the person above me, I rate their avatar as a six, and their signature as a 8, so average score would be 7 overall.

[Captain Monmoo]

Sig rules = http://75.126.43.122/forum/showthread.php?t=18950

Avatar... a 5 because I can't figure out what its a picture of. O_o

[Liam Jinn]

I don't even know if I have a sig anymore.

[Banner Laverick]

Nope, you dont. Liams' avatar gets an 8, mostly because of the pink text and "?" above the sheeps head :)

[Park Kraken]

Banner's Avatar and Sig rate a 8 and 6 overall (6 because of the Spiderman doll thing? she's holding) which rates a 7 overall.

[Dallas Walker]

The doll has the same suit as her IC-bf :p lol.

Kraken gets a 7!

edit - no-one wants to rate me because I'm hideously disfigured *weeps*

[Aurelias Kazaar]

I have to be honest, I know nothing about Dallas Walker (since I admittedly don't read X-men). But I like how the sigs were done. They match well with the avatars and you did a nice job at 'disfiguring' Joker into its own character.

9/10 for both avatar and sig.

P.S. Blood spatters are a nice addition to it.

[Liam Jinn]

You kids are sweet, nothing in this thread deserves better than a 6, if that. 4 for everyone.

[Vega Van-Derveld]

-1 for Liam :mneh

[Lilaena De'Ville]

*bans Liam*

[Aurelias Kazaar]

Ah he's just mad the Cows haven't fired Wade 'mister Fix-It' Phillips yet.

The LD 'Bloodstained Hands' one is an excellent signature. Fits the avatar very well too.

9/10 on both.

[Grace Van-Derveld]

I would like to rate this avatar IC

1

:shootin

^_^

I would say an 8 overall. I like the sin city feel to your sig (The one with Kazaar and the gun, Estelle in the background), but something about the avatar choice makes me wanna flick his tongue :lol

[Nya Halcyon]

Gotta say, I love the sig (the one that says "My Shadow's the only one that walks beside me" and has the pic of Grace holding the gun and Dasq in the background with lines crisscrossing the image). It's sharp and uncluttered and somehow very elegant. So I'm giving it a 10.

Avatar's matching nicely, so it's a 10 overall.

[Hera]

Grace -

The sig showing is the one where Grace is looking pensive with the Rebel symbol in the bg. It looks kind of sparkly.

I give it an 8 for prettiness and style, but it seems too gentle for the Grace we know and love.
The one that Nya rated, I give a 10.

Nya - an 8 for your avatar.

[Kanji]

I show the stats-card signature for you Hera, and I give it an 7. It fits the profile theme pretty well, but a nitpick as I am occasionally - there's a few pixels out of place on the SWFans.net logo on the right which overlaps into the white-bound box.

Otherwise, I like it!

Ps. SwFans Trading Cards, anyone?

[Ever Talbot]

Trading cards were already done :)

You only have a sig, it's simple and I like it. The text at the top is a bit hard to read (mostly where it covers the cloud). I give it a 6.5 cos no avatar makes me sad :(

[Lykaios]

6 on the avatar cause I don't want it to fail but it's too simple for me.

Beware my rotating sigs! Huzzah!

[Razielle Alastor]

6 on the avatar cause I don't want it to fail but it's too simple for me.

Yeah, but it amazingly fits really well. XD

As for you! 9/10 they are hubba hubba. :D

(and mine rotates too!)

[Adia Issoris]

Avatar - 10 - THose violet eyes are the sexiest doom.
Sig - I got the red one. 9/10. I'm not sure it's the best font, and maybe the text should be more red than rose.

[Sanya Tagge]

Avatar - Oh Julianne Moore :love She looks kind of wistful though, not exactly what I'd expect of Adia for some reason... 8
Sig - Blood splatter and silohuette. Very stylish! 9

[Lykaios]

9.5 on both the Avi and the Siggie both of them HAWT!

[Callista]

You are not showing a sig sir!

9 on your avatar :) the blue on the bottom is bugging me....and I made that didn't I... *facepalm*

[Kyran O'Hurn]

8 on the avi and the siggie... Do like the eye treatment she got..

PS. My sig's on rotate

[Wyl Staedtler]

I got the 'did I stutter' sig. Took me a second to notice the Rebel insignia on the cue ball. Very cool :D I really like the selective use of colour too - 8/10

Av - 9; it goes very well with the character and sig.


I, too, am of the rotating sig club. ;)

[Oddity]

I got the red "boy wonder" sig...Wyl is SO creepy looking in it! XD

Avatar - 8
Sig - 6.5 (only cos it's creepy, which I do not associate with Wyl at all!)

[Lykaios]

9 on the avi...cause it's HQ!

8.5 on the sig cause I think it's got some fuzziness *hopes it's not his screen*




You are not showing a sig sir!

9 on your avatar :) the blue on the bottom is bugging me....and I made that didn't I... *facepalm*
Yup, yup you did and now that you've pointed it out I can't stop staring at that blue thing, so *waves to avi* adios!!!

[Tri'ahna Zylary]

Where did your sig go? I know you had one, because I saw it.... getting a new one then?

Anyway, I give the new avatar an 8 for cuteness. It doesn't look like an Inquisitor tho...

[Dasquian Belargic]

Avatar - 9. I like the wide-eyed look.

Sig - 8. It's cool, but not the best work I've seen you do.

[Yeart Quenn]

You've got a new Avatar!

Is that the same actor?!? Anyway, I love it. Very classy. 10!

(Oh, and my Tria ones are both a bit boring.... still haven't figured out where to take the char, really, so there's no depth to it yet... just face and name... *sigh*)

[Dasquian Belargic]

It's a different actor :)

10 for Yeart. I love everything about his look. So fitting.

[Charlotte Tur'enne]

10. I really, really like the new avi. The composition and pretty much everything about it is just awesome.

(rando sig here, but only two of them)

[Dasquian Belargic]

10.

Love for the snark. VMars is the perfect choice for Charles. :D

[Elias Akasha]

I agree with the consensus so far - the avatar looks really classy. Bonus marks for the choice of new face as well. The important question is though, does Dasquian speak in his gravelly farmer's voice? ;)

Love the signature as well; in contrast with the avatar, the ensemble nicely shows two totally different sides of Dasquian's story. There's something about how rugged the signature seems as well that really works.

10!

[Loklorien s'Ilancy]

The colors are great and really pop out at you. I like the transparency of the character, as it lends a bit of mystery to him. And somehow, it seems you've managed to match up the guy in your avatar with the illustration in the sig. Color me impressed :) Overall I give it a 9.


Eventually I'm going to get a rotating sig, but for now here's my new avatar/sig combo.

[Aurelias Kazaar]

Avatar/sig combination....11 of 10 points possible.

[Dasquian Belargic]

8 for the avatar. His expression, with the tongue stuck out, makes me laugh.

10 for the Sin City style sig (not the one I made). I like the bars of light over Estelle, very noir.

[Leliel]

Already gave you a 10...

But I wanted an excuse to post this one.

[Razielle Alastor]

9 - because it has purple, I approve.

[Kal Olorin]

7 for Step into my Parlour siggeh, I like it just it doesn't WAM hit me between the eyes with awesomeness. :)

[Razielle Alastor]

10 - for having a dreamy av.

-2 for voting on a sig that was not there! :twak:p

I keed, very nice. All your sigs are. :)

[Dasquian Belargic]

Avatar - 9. the eyeeesssss..

Sigs - even though I made them... 8. They aren't my favorite Raz's ever.



I have two signatures now! :D rotator ftw.

[Tell Cho]

I wonder if the Empire charged Belargic for that cosmetic surgery... I give it an 8: simple but effective.

EDIT: I see no Seegnatoors, Meester Behlahrgik.

[Nathanial K'cansce]

I'll give you an 8 on the avatar. It's cool stuff.

[RC-1197]

Well.... avatar is creepy, kinda. But simple. Which is good. Blends in well on a black background. I give it a 7.

And sig: I like it because I like Johnny Depp, but in itself the design is a bit bare. I'd say a 6.

[Void]

The armor sets in the sig and avatar don't really match, but apart from that they're both great. The art is neat, and I like the... Hamlet-esque holding of the droids head :D 8 overall.

[s'Il]

I'm liking how the avatar and the sig show two different sides of your character (if indeed that's what you were going for), and the yellow text boxes bring them together neatly for the viewer. Overall I give it a 9 :)

[Arya Ravenwing]

9! Image manips are very good.

>_o my sigs are almost all years and years old. I think its time for a clean start. But rate anyway!

[Crusader]

The horizontial picture of trinity where she is lieing on the ground.
I like the font and the choice of picture but the text on the left is hard to read so I will give you an 8.

My signature is a WIP so I am looking forward to some constructive criticism.
EDIT: Oh and obviously it is not working correctly right now...I will attach it for the moment

[Arya Ravenwing]

Ok I have a new sig, please rate it! Hopefully I'll get a semi-matching avvie soonish

Oh and Crusader I give your sig av combo a 9 for matchiness without being too matchy-matchy, and a 4 for composition, so overall a 6. :)

[Byl Laprovik]

The sig gets an 8. Pretty good expectation of what's to come from a lupine brawler without being too self-explanatory or busy.

The avatar is a five. The text isn't really readable and distracts from the eyes, which should be hogging the attention.

[Morgan Evanar]

That's a good avatar I give it a very solid 8.


Be honest...

about how awesome I am.

[Valerie Alterson]

I have to give you a 10, as always. :)

[Zenas Codrey]

Don't know anything about your character, so I can't really speak to how well the images fit her personality or anything. However, comma, the avatar has a mysterious appeal that's actually more attractive than the signature. I don't wanna say the signature is too plain, because I'm not sure you want anything distracting from your lovely naked lady, but I DO know that something needs to happen with that text! "Centered is for tombstones" is a rather common sentiment around our school's graphic design department. >_< I might also consider chopping the number of distinct fonts down to 2.[/constructive criticism.

So, is it numbers time? 8 on the av, 6 on the sig, with the number climbing if my head starts tilting and I zone out. ^_^;

I have avatar art now! I'll make a signature when I have the time, but for now, rate the quality of my (custom made!) avatar art. :D Here's the bigger version, for those of you that care (or want to be charitable and make me a signature):

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v503/Feist/kl_togruta.jpg

[Lilaena De'Ville]

Ok rate me again!

[Aurelias Kazaar]

Umm...wow?

9/10 on both but I liked the older ones.

[Razielle Alastor]

10 - awesome, of course.
(voting on the 'action is eloquence' one, with Estelle)

[Rossos Atrapes]

Testing... testing... one, two... one... two...

I now have two siggies! And they rotate! Go me! I'm slowly getting fancier. I know they're bare right now, but I figured that since I'm rusty with Photoshop, I'll go with the age old mantra, "Keep it simple, stupid!"

Depending on whether I have more schoolwork I want to procrastinate for, I might update them and make them fancier; but we'll see. And oh, I give the Avatar: it's simple, and I like that, and the eyes are freaking lavender. Awesome. 9. Signature: "We know when to kiss..." - Very nice. 9 12/15.

Please, let me down gently.

[Aurelias Kazaar]

I like both of them. They fit your avatar well and sometimes simplicity is the best way to go.

9/10 for both of them.

This one, hasn't been uploaded yet but I did this last night. Somehow :lol

[Jamie Morrigan]

You've had several great expressionistic avatars; this one fits in well. I love the film noir/black-and-white motif you've got going with your sigs. :)

This particular sig, though, there are some compositing issues, and that picture of Mili really gives me some difficulty... the lighting is from directyl overhead while it's to the right of both Estelle and Aurelias, and the contrast is lower, which makes Mili look like she was cut out of a newspaper and pasted on. She also looks a bit stretched? It's a good idea, but the composition needs some work. You've got plenty of other great sigs, though.

8/10 avatar
5/10 sig

[Zelenka Lassiter]

10/10 on the avi, I rather like the composition/lighting and that added bit of text is just amusing. Don't know a whole lot about the character but she seems up to no good and that's always a bonus :D

9/10 on the sig...just because there doesn't seem a whole lot there, but it works for some reason...and the "crazy!" gets a giggle out of me whenever I see it

[Tear]

Oh gods, Jennifer Connolly, I would defect for you!:love

Oh, right... I forgot to rate. 10's across the board!

[Xavier Synik]

A full Zeltron Jennifer Connolly...

Now that's dangerous...

[Dasquian Belargic]

Rebel Intelligence: It's Where The Hotties Are :smokin

[Mu Satach]

Xavier Synik - love the expression on the avatar 8,
nice double moon/planet and coloring the edges to match the halo around the figure. US currency interesting, 7ish?

[Ariadne Fyrian]

Avatar - 10
It's simple but the piercing gaze is what makes it.

Sig - 8
I love the main background image and the placement of the white text, but the the blue text and the secondary image on the left kind of distract from the overall feeling I think you're trying to convey.

:)

[Sudoku]

9 for the avatar
10 for the sig, I like the back tattoo

I had a new sig in the works, but PS died :( please be kind on my humble signature XD

[Malick Raine]

10 for both very simple but nice. :)


(this be my latest attempt at sig making)

[Kassandra]

8

Editting is pretty good, and I do enjoy some Jensen Ackles :D

[Nicky Raine]

9.5 it reminds me of LOTR for some reason. I always liked that Avi.

[Aree Ankarta]

The avatar looks amazingly insane, in some way. I have no idea about the character but somehow she looks like she could scour things alright...

Sig is great, too - showing the "ages" part.

I give it a 10 overall.


EDIT: Nicky posted while I was replying, so mine's obviously about Kassandra.

Oh, and my char is a fashionable Mando who has several sets of Armour to dress for the occasion ;) That's why avatar and sig armour don't quite match....

[Blade Bacquin]

9.5 very well done.

(This sig looked awesome until it came to sizing it then it turned to crap. :( )

[Penelope Lloyd-Fraser]

The avatar has just a hint of a smirk that seems very Blade-like.

I see what you mean about the sizing squishing the sig, though. Pity.

[Kala'ndryl Ryj]

8

I like the expression, and the fact that she's not looking straight at the camera (is that a screenshot?) makes it doubly interesting.

*prods gently* I see no sig though...:(

[Dalamar DeSang]

Its an older sig but Im interested in a rating... ;/ Ohh my bad hmmnn actually pretty cool the sun in the symbol her purple eyes. And that quote that sounds so familiar whats that from...

[Dakota Gue]

psst, you gots to rate the one above Dal ;)

I rate yours a 7.5 on the sig, a 9 on the avatar.

The sig writing (font I guess) is a little unclear to read and his symbol is a bit too dominating for the picture imo. On the other hand, I love the Avatar pic as it says it all in one small frame.

[Dalamar DeSang]

yeah its old. Lord of the "Eye of the dragon" that board has been gone a long while. Still thanks for the rating.. I guess I should also rate yours. Minimalistic appproach which fits the character. No frills just action for her... 7.5

Go's to change to more modern sig..

[Dalamar DeSang]

Hows this one more modern.. and hopefully clean.

[Phebe Caras]

avi is 8 old school but still works. no sig though.

[Sanya Tagge]

7 - she looks awfully shy, hiding behind that hair.


New avatar for Sanya, same sig.

[Aurelias Kazaar]

Oo nice avatar. I like how you're using pics from 'The Black Dahlia' (I think) for the sig and avatar. Good job :)

[Estelle Russard]

10 on both Avy and Sig (the Frack off/No hero one).

They are so eloquent of the character you write.

[Dasquian Belargic]

Sig is one with both Estelle and Kazaar. Really professional looking. Also maeks me wonder what the Aurbesh (I think that's what its called?) text means. 9.5!

Avatar is pretty, and I like the 'Face of Rebellion' tagline a lot.

[Nya Halcyon]

The Aurabesh is the first few lines of their Personnel files: name, codename, planet of birth, etc... (I think, I don't remember exactly anymore...). Basically, I made up something from their wiki pages...

[Remon Jore]

Jen, I rated your Dasquian sig before (and I'm not gonna rate my own avatar just above... :p )

So here's one I scrambled together hastily for this character. Not happy with it, but Gimp just sucks....

[Eve Siren]

8 ! I love it, I just wish the font color would be a bit clearer. Love the avatar too, very distinguished.

[Dasquian Belargic]

7 - Needs more Jessica Alba :mneh



Got myself a new avatar. What do you think?

[Carré Inirial]

Love it - thou receivest a 10 :)

[Darth Callidus]

9

I think the pose in the sig is especially great. Very Carre.

[Akasha Khan]

New avatar and sig combo! :cat

[Dasquian Belargic]

Ooh, that looks great :D

[Droo]

New avatar and sig combo! :cat

Big big big improvement! Nice one!